How realistic is the 2027 Yorktown budget?

Posted

After two days of meetings with department heads totaling 10 hours, the Town Board voted 3-2 to adopt a 2027 preliminary budget for the Dec. 1 budget public hearing.

The budget added $265,000 in expenditures to the supervisor’s tentative budget, but at the same time, reduced the proposed increase in the “town” tax rate to 3.48% from 4.98% in the supervisor’s budget. There were no changes in the other tax rates.

There’s an old saying: you don’t always want to know how the sausage was made. I disagree. I believe you should know how budgets are crafted, especially if you plan to continue living and paying taxes in Yorktown.

Because the two budget meetings were open to the public but were not televised, what follows is a recap that explains how the board raised spending and cut the “town” tax rate at the same time.

Expenditure additions

While the supervisor’s budget incorporated input from department heads, with two exceptions, this was the department heads’ first meeting with the full board and their opportunity to ask for additional funds that the supervisor had rejected or that they had not previously requested.

Throughout the meetings, the Finance Department kept a running list of these requested “add-ons.” Surprisingly, when the board was ready to discuss if it wanted to change any budget lines, there was a consensus that most of the add-ons were needed.

The problem then was how to fund $265,000 in additional expenditures without raising the “town” tax rate beyond the 4.98% in the supervisor’s budget. Councilman Murphy said he would not accept an increase greater than the 3.5% cost-of-living adjustment (COLA).

That left two choices: cut some expenditures or raise revenue. I suggested cuts; Councilman Sergio Esposito said we needed more revenue.

My suggested cuts included $60,000 for the town’s public relations consultant; $52,000 for the grant writer who has not obtained any significant grants; the 3% raise for board members; a budgeted but vacant Planning Department position; and some part-time museum hours. All were resoundingly rejected. No alternative cuts were offered.

That left raising revenue as the only option.

Revenue increases

The first possibility was using more fund balance, already budgeted at $1.25 million. After Councilman Ilan Gilbert opposed the suggestion to use an additional $625,000, the board settled on taking only an additional $250,000.

But that wasn’t enough to lower the increase in the tax rate.

So the board turned to revenue projections. And although the comptroller explained that she had already maxed them out, the budget ended up adding $350,000 in revenue, most likely in the sales and mortgage tax and fines collected.

The 'no' votes

Councilman Esposito voted against the budget because it exceeded the 2% tax cap. This was despite the comptroller explaining that the only way to stay within the cap would be to eliminate the tax levy for the Hallocks Mill sewer fund, which would effectively mean shutting down the sewage treatment plant.

I voted against the budget because it was unrealistic: too many expense lines were under budgeted on the assumption that prices might fall; just last week the board had to transfer $755,500 from fund balance and other budget lines to cover 2026 under budgeted lines. I also believed that some revenue projections were overly optimistic plus my long held position that fund balance should be used to cover long term capital projects, emergencies and major unanticipated expenses, not recurring operating costs.

Future budgets

There were also discussions that could affect future budgets.

  • Refuse fund. Although the contract with the refuse company has one more year, with an option to renew for another, the board asked the Refuse Department to look into what the cost to homeowners would be if they had to contract on their own.

  • Hallocks Mill sewer fund: The town-owned sewage treatment plant is in serious trouble. The fund will need millions of dollars to repair, replace or upgrade multiple systems.

  • Peekskill sewer operating fund. Expense and revenue projections for this new fund are very rough. It will take a year to gather better numbers for the 2028 budget.

  • Paving. Superintendent Dave Paganelli suggested that instead of the annual $1 million budget line, sometimes supplemented from fund balance, the town borrow $8 million so roads can be paved sooner than later and that the annual state CHIPS money be used to pay the debt service.

  • Capital plan. While Superintendent Paganelli said he would need $1.2 million to replace a culvert on Whitehill Road, and Recreation Commission Chairman Matt Talbert outlined several projects, there was no discussion of which capital projects might be funded in 2027. And although the “unassigned fund balance” (money available to spend) was $24 million as of December 2025, the comptroller advised that given 2026 drawdowns and other factors, the fund balance would be several million dollars lower going into 2027.

What happens next?

That’s up to you. What level of services do you want, and how much are you willing to pay for them, today and tomorrow? If you want to avoid tax increases, are you willing to distinguish between needs and wants? Equipment needs don’t disappear, delaying infrastructure repairs typically raises future costs, and costs are likely to go up, not down.

Which tax increase strategy would you prefer: yearly increases of 2%-3% based on realistic budgets, or alternating years of zero increases followed by 7% increases?

Board members need to hear what you want. Attend the December 1 budget hearing, which starts at 6:30 p.m., or email or phone all five Town Board members.

Susan Siegel is a member of the Yorktown Town Board.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here