A Westchester County grand jury has declined to indict a retired New York City police lieutenant in the August shooting death of a dog in Yorktown Heights, bringing the criminal proceedings against him to a close.
Westchester County District Attorney Susan Cacace announced Friday that the grand jury returned a "no true bill" in the case against James Molloy, who was arrested Aug. 5 after fatally shooting Luke, a 12-year-old shepherd-husky mix, in a parking lot near the former Turco's property along Route 118.
Molloy had been charged with aggravated cruelty to animals, a class E felony, and first-degree reckless endangerment, a class D felony.
The shooting occurred around 7:15 p.m. Aug. 5 when Luke, who belonged to Matt Steele, a well-known homeless man in the community, broke free from his leash and ran toward Molloy, who was walking a volunteer therapy dog.
Luke, also known as "Snoopy," was a beloved fixture in the Yorktown community alongside his owner. The dog's death prompted an outpouring of support for Steele, with dozens of residents gathering outside Yorktown Justice Court in August carrying "Justice for Luke" signs.
At Molloy's Aug. 11 court appearance, residents described Luke as Steele's closest companion, with one saying the two had "kept each other alive." Yorktown resident Giulio Eliseo said Luke had belonged to Steele's late mother and that Steele had refused to enter a shelter because he would not give up his dog. Eliseo said community members regularly checked on the pair and described Luke as Steele's remaining connection to his family.
In the weeks following Luke's death, Steele also lost his longtime place to stay after its management company revoked his permission to remain there. With assistance from friends, he relocated to another private property in Yorktown in late August. Luke's remains, which had been held for testing by the District Attorney's Office, were later released, and his ashes were returned to Steele by Rainbow Bridge Pet Crematory in Yorktown.
Molloy's attorney, Robert M. Schechter of Tilem & Associates, previously maintained that his client acted in self-defense when he shot Luke.
“What is true is that James Molloy defended himself against an attack from an aggressive dog in a public space,” Schechter told Yorktown News in August. “James regrets that his actions in self-defense resulted in the death of a beloved animal. Anyone who loves an animal feels that loss and sadness.”
According to Cacace, police records indicated that Luke was barking aggressively before lunging at Molloy and the therapy dog. Molloy attempted to stop Luke's advance by swinging his arms but was unsuccessful.
Molloy then fired a single shot from a firearm he was legally authorized to carry, striking Luke in the mouth and killing him.
The Yorktown Police Department investigated the shooting with assistance from the Westchester County SPCA Humane Law Enforcement Division.
The grand jury began hearing testimony Monday and concluded its proceedings Wednesday. Eight witnesses testified, including three Yorktown police officers, three civilians, Molloy and an expert forensic veterinarian who conducted Luke's necropsy, a post-mortem examination of an animal's body to determine the cause of death or investigate disease.
According to the District Attorney's Office, the necropsy findings indicated that Luke, who weighed 96 pounds, was facing Molloy with his mouth open, teeth bared and body lowered in a pouncing stance when he was shot.
The forensic veterinarian testified that Luke was less than a second away from reaching and attacking Molloy when the shot was fired.
The expert also testified that dogs of Luke's breed are capable of inflicting dangerous and potentially fatal bites and that Luke was poised to bite Molloy had he not been stopped.
After reviewing the evidence and receiving instructions on the applicable charges, the grand jury determined there was insufficient evidence to establish reasonable cause to indict Molloy.
Molloy's Oct. 13 court appearance had previously been adjourned to Dec. 8. However, the grand jury's decision brings the criminal proceedings against him to a close.
In a statement following the decision, Juda Engelmayer, who handles communications for Molloy through his attorneys, said the former NYPD lieutenant was relieved by the outcome after months of public scrutiny and maintained that he had acted out of fear for his safety.
“This is an important outcome for Jim, who has spent months living with uncertainty, public criticism, and questions about his character and judgment,” the statement said.
“Jim's life should not be defined by this one incident. He is a retired police officer who spent decades serving the public, a man recovering from major heart surgery, a devoted dog owner, and someone who continues to give his time each week to help children facing serious medical challenges.”
The statement also acknowledged the community's grief over Luke's death.
“We recognize that the loss of a pet is deeply upsetting, particularly for its owners. Nothing about today's decision diminishes that loss or the emotions surrounding what happened,” the statement said. “Jim understands that grief and has never sought to minimize it.
The statement also said Molloy plans to focus on his family, his recovery and his volunteer work visiting hospitalized children with his therapy dog.
Under New York state law, grand jury proceedings are confidential and cannot be publicly disclosed without a court order.
In the interest of transparency, the District Attorney's Office petitioned the court for permission to disclose information about the evidence presented to the grand jury.
Judge Robert J. Prisco granted the request, authorizing the District Attorney's Office to publicly disclose details of the grand jury proceedings and the evidence presented in the case.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here