Large community presence expected at Yorktown court in dog’s fatal shooting

Town officials are anticipating a large community presence at tonight’s Yorktown Justice Court appearance in the case involving a resident accused of fatally shooting a dog belonging to a beloved homeless man near the former Turco’s last week.

The case has generated strong emotions in the community, with residents creating a memorial for the dog, Luke, and many rallying behind his owner, Matt.

Residents have vowed to attend the 6 p.m. Tuesday appearance of 61-year-old James Molloy, who faces charges of first-degree reckless endangerment, a Class D felony, and aggravated cruelty to animals, a Class E felony. 

 It was not immediately clear whether Matt would attend the appearance.

The anticipated turnout prompted town officials to remind those attending that they must follow court rules and maintain appropriate behavior during the proceedings.

“I want to emphasize that our Town Court is a place where the rule of law prevails and where every individual is entitled to a fair and impartial proceeding, regardless of the allegations against them,” said Supervisor Ed Lachterman in a statement from the town’s public relations firm.

The court appearance is open to members of the media and the public, but attendees must follow court rules.

“Disruptive or disrespectful behavior, including outbursts or attempts to interfere with the proceedings, will not be tolerated,” Lachterman said. “The judge and court officers have a responsibility to maintain order and decorum in the courtroom so that justice can be carried out fairly and safely for everyone present.”

No video, audio recording or photography is permitted inside Yorktown Justice Court under New York state court rules. Cellphones and other electronic devices may be brought into the courtroom but must be silenced. Officials said that attendees must follow all instructions from court personnel.

“I ask all those who choose to attend to respect the court, respect the process, and respect one another,” Lachterman said. “Our community can show its concern and its values while still upholding the fundamental legal rights that protect us all.”