Court Upholds Yorktown’s District Overlay Law

Posted

Yorktown, N.Y. -- A 2022 lawsuit to overturn the Town Board’s approval of the Yorktown Heights overlay district was denied by the state Supreme Court late last month. 

The Planned Design District Overlay Law, which was approved in December 2021, laid out new zones for certain properties in Lake Osceola and Yorktown Heights to promote economic growth by encouraging mixed-use development. 

Filed in April of last year, an Article 78 lawsuit was brought by a local organization founded by Trish Sullivan-Rothberg, a former Town Board candidate. Also named as plaintiffs were neighboring residents Martha Dodenhoff, Susan and Steve Dolled, and Louise Fang.

An Article 78 lawsuit under the State Environmental Quality Review Act lets plaintiffs sue to have an action invalidated if the court deems the environmental review process incomplete or inadequate.

The plaintiffs challenged the legality of the district in Yorktown Heights but did not include the Osceola district in the suit.

The suit argued that the overlay zone (and developments being considered within it) eroded the historic aspects of the Yorktown Heights hamlet. The developments, Underhill Farm at the intersection of Underhill Avenue and Route 118, as well as the Gardena Hotel, were both approved earlier this year. 

The lawsuit argued that the rezoning violated town law and that the Town Board failed to perform the necessary environmental review. It also said the town failed to consider the “cumulative impacts” of the rezoning before making its decision. 

The overlay zone was adopted during former supervisor (and current state assemblyman) Matt Slater’s tenure in town government. 

In ruling for the town, State Supreme Court Judge George Fufidio concluded that the overlay district complies with the State Environment Quality Review Act, and said the town had properly weighed its impact and challenged the notion that Yorktown should remain focused on low-density housing.

“The dynamics of change are always at play and would seem to be even more so in an area so close to one of the world’s largest urban areas,” Fufidio wrote in his decision. “With that in mind, zoning schemes are not static, and while zoning laws do promote a developmental and systemic foundation when the winds of change shift, they are not meant to be a bulwark against any kind of change.

“It is clear that his endeavor was undertaken to revitalize and modernize a flagging commercial district in Yorktown,” he added. “The town reasonably took into account the foreseeable needs of the community and was guided by the town’s Comprehensive Plan and sound zoning principles as well as by state and local laws with which they were in compliance and the whole plan was carried out in a proper, careful and reasonable manner. The past should not unnecessarily constrain the future.”

The decision was praised by both Slater and current Supervisor Tom Diana.

“The current and former members of the Town Board were thoughtful, deliberate, and respectful of all our obligations under the town’s Comprehensive Plan. We adopted this overlay zoning ordinance with the goal of bringing an economic rebirth to our business hamlets that have struggled for years because of changes in the retail landscape,” Diana said in a prepared statement. “This overlay zoning is intended to position Yorktown businesses for success, and that’s where we are headed.”

A statement from Slater’s office said that the overlay district was the “cornerstone” of his economic development plan while in the supervisor’s chair. It states it was also part of his Reboot Yorktown Task Force which convened after the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic. 

“The court’s ruling validates the great care we used to craft an economic development plan that will revitalize the Yorktown Heights business district,” Slater said. “The Overlay District law has been the key to attracting millions of dollars in new private investment in Yorktown Heights and it will continue to transform our town and grow the local commercial tax base.”

John Ravitz, executive vice president and executive operating officer for the Business Council of Westchester (BCW) was quoted in the release stating, “The Business Council of Westchester recognized early on that then-Supervisor Slater was trying to think outside of the box and crafted an economic development approach that could be a model for local governments across the state and nation. 

“Matt’s approach will transform the Yorktown Heights Hamlet by making it more attractive to potential businesses and economic development projects. We applaud the court’s decision and are excited for Yorktown’s future,” Ravitz wrote. 

Approved Projects in Overlay District

The approved Underhill Farm project is a mixed-use development consisting of 48 townhouses, a 32-unit 55-plus senior restricted condominium building, and a mixed-use building consisting of 68 apartments and 15,600 square feet of retail/office space that includes 8,100 square foot of new retail space in addition to the reuse of the Underhill Farmhouse.

Additionally, the Town Board approved an agreement with the developer, Underhill Soundview LLC, that will deliver full reconstruction of the intersection at Route 118 and Underhill Avenue. The developer committed $225,000 to the town to fund improvements to public parks and over $625,000 toward the estimated $1.2 million intersection costs.

The Gardena Hotel, according to the approved site plans, is a three-story, 18-room hotel that is slated for the corner of Veterans Road and Commerce Street. It will feature a café, a rooftop bar and grill, and off-street parking.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here