How NYS is quietly defunding the police

Posted

I doubt you are aware of how New York State is quietly undermining local police departments, particularly in small and medium-sized communities that rely on part-time police officers.

To understand what is happening, we need to go back nearly 20 years. In 2007, retired police officers who wanted to return to law enforcement while collecting their pensions were permitted to earn $30,000 annually. Today, nearly 20 years later, that limit has increased to just $35,000.

Think about that for a moment. In almost two decades, the allowable earnings limit has increased by only $5,000, despite the rising cost of living.

I know what some people are thinking: These officers already receive a pension. Yes, they do. But anyone living in the Hudson Valley understands that a pension alone may not be enough to cover today's expenses.

Here is where this becomes your problem.

Small towns and villages depend on retired police officers to supplement and staff their departments and provide coverage. These experienced officers can work part-time without requiring the municipality to provide another full-time salary and benefits package. Their pensions and benefits generally come from their former employers, while their new departments pay them just an hourly rate. That is a huge savings!

Unfortunately, New York State's outdated earnings cap makes these positions increasingly unattractive.

Why would an experienced, retired police officer continue working in law enforcement when they could earn two or three times as much in the private sector? Many simply choose other opportunities.

That leaves local police chiefs with fewer qualified officers to choose from, making recruitment and retention increasingly difficult. In my own experience, there have been times this year when I had no applicants to consider for available positions.

This is not just a staffing problem. It is a public safety problem.

When departments cannot recruit and retain enough officers, communities feel the consequences. Shifts go unfilled, coverage is reduced, and police chiefs are forced to make difficult decisions about how to deploy the personnel they have.

Training is another concern. Law enforcement is constantly changing, and officers need ongoing training to remain effective and up to date. But every dollar an officer donates to training no matter how important, is an hour less they are able to protect the community.

Ask police chiefs throughout the Hudson Valley who operate departments with part-time officers. Many have faced situations in which they have had to shorten shifts or eliminate them altogether because they simply do not have enough personnel available.

How does that make our communities safer?

New York State should be encouraging experienced officers to remain in law enforcement, not creating financial disincentives that push them away.

So, what needs to happen? Why the governor?

The reason the governor needs to have it in the budget is because local state representatives co-sponsor legislation for the cap to be increased but that never goes anywhere. You see, in Albany, all the bills have to go into a committee and then if it gets voted out, it goes to the floor for a vote. You guessed it, these bills never come out of committee for a vote and stay buried until the session is over. Or one branch will pass it one year and the other won’t. Then the next year the other one will pass it. It is like a game.

The governor needs to make this a priority and include an increase in the earnings limit in the state budget. The current $35,000 cap should be raised to at least $65,000 annually. That would be a more realistic limit in today's economy and would allow experienced officers to contribute more hours to the communities that need them.

And before someone argues that the state cannot do this, consider retired public school teachers.

New York State has recognized the importance of allowing retired teachers to return to work under different earnings-limit rules. I know this issue from both sides of the profession: I am a retired teacher with 36 years of service, and I understand the value of retaining experienced people in public service.

I also understand that some will argue that there is a shortage of teachers. There may be, but there is also a shortage of police officers. Both professions are important to our communities, and both deserve policies that recognize the value of experience.

The difference is that teachers have a strong, organized voice advocating for their interests. Part-time police officers and the small communities that depend on them do not have the same influence in Albany.

The result is an earnings cap that has barely changed in nearly 20 years, while the cost of living has continued to climb.

This is not a request for more funding to build larger police departments. It is a request to remove an outdated restriction that prevents local governments from making better use of experienced officers they can already afford to employ.

Allowing retired officers to earn more could help towns and villages maintain coverage, provide necessary training, improve recruitment and retention.

New York State needs to recognize that this is a public safety issue, not simply a pension issue.

Our communities deserve adequate police protection. Our local governments need the flexibility to provide it. And experienced officers who are willing to continue serving should not be discouraged from doing so by an earnings limit that no longer reflects economic reality.

The governor should raise the cap to at least $65,000 and include that change in the state budget.

The question is simple: If experienced police officers are willing to serve our communities, why is New York State making it harder for them to do so?

Thomas S. Howley is chief of the North Salem Police Department.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here